Is coal blocking clean energy expansion in Australia and India?

Despite getting the Australian government’s go-ahead for its Carmichael coal mine and rail project in that country, the Indian company, the Adani Group is likely to exercise caution before starting more work on the project. There also remains the inability of Adani Enterprises, which has a market capitalisation of $1.6 billion, to raise funding for the greenfield mine, rail and port project. Meanwhile, renewable energy opportunities abound in India as the report by IFEEFA states the Indian Government is on track to achieve its goals of modernising the electricity grid and installing 175GW of renewable energy, underpinning sustained economic growth in India of 6-8% pa. But India still has plans to double domestic coal production. Read More

Adani Project in Australia: Many Rivers to Cross

Dev Chatterjee for the Business Standard (15 October):

Despite getting the Australian government’s go-ahead for its Carmichael coal mine and rail project in that country, the Adani Group is likely to exercise caution before starting more work on the project.

According to Tim Buckley, Director of Energy Finance Studies at the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis, the Australian federal government had previously issued environmental approval, but made a material procedural error in the process which environment minister Greg Hunt rectified today.

However, he said, the government’s approval is still being challenged in a case currently before the Queensland Land Court, and a decision is expected in the next 3-6 months.

Further, he said, Adani is yet to reach an agreement with the traditional owners of land, the W&J people.

Once these issues are resolved, there remains the inability of Adani Enterprises, which has a market capitalisation of $1.6 billion, to raise funding for the greenfield mine, rail and port project.

“With 15 of the largest global financial institutions ruling out this project or walking away from advisory roles, I would suggest the project is unbankable. The 6% year-on-year decline in Indian utility companies’ thermal coal imports in the six months to September 2015 likewise shows coal and power minister Piyush Goyal’s aim to cease Indian thermal imports is happening far faster than anyone expected. This also removes any long term strategic logic that was originally behind the proposal,” Buckley said.

http://ieefa.org/adani-project-in-australia-many-rivers-to-cross/

India’s Electricity-Sector Transformation

New IEEFA report (10 August 2015):

India’s energy transformation gathers momentum

India’s ‘seven horses of energy’ electricity sector transformation is gathering pace, with far-reaching ramifications for renewable energy development and the structural decline of seaborne thermal coal, according to a new report released today by the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis (IEEFA) and Indian energy analysis firm, Equitorials.

The report – India’s Electricity Sector Transformation – states the Indian Government is on track to achieve its goals of doubling domestic coal production, modernising the electricity grid and installing 175GW of renewable energy, underpinning sustained economic growth in India of 6-8% pa.

“The profound transformation announced in 2014 by the Indian government is gaining momentum,” said Tim Buckley, Director of Energy Finance Studies at IEEFA. “While most financial commentators have questioned India’s capacity to deliver, all sign are pointing towards success.”

The installation of 175GW of renewable energy – equivalent to three times the electricity capacity of Australia – is one of a number of key policy initiatives that will enable the rapid transformation.

“India has opened the gates to a wave of multi-billion dollar investments in its renewable energy sector,” said Buckley. “There have been eight major deals in July alone with the single biggest international endorsement being SoftBanks’ US$20bn, 20GW solar joint venture.”

Major 2015 renewable energy deals include:

• In July 2015 French energy giant ENGIE was reported to be in the process of acquiring three leading Indian solar developers with a 2GW solar pipeline;
• May 2015 US$700 million investment in a 450MW wind farm and recapitalisation of Suzlon Energy by one of India’s richest men, Dilip Shangvi;
• February 2015 announcement of aUS$4bn venture between Adani Enterprises and SunEdison to build an integrated, world-scale module manufacturing facility;
• February 2015 NTPC Limited of India proposal to invest US$10bn to fund the development of 10GW of renewables within the next five years. In May 2015 NTPC also announced a 420MW Invitation for Bids for the Bhadla Phase-II Solar Park in Rajasthan and a second for 500MW at the Gani-Sakunala Solar Park in Andhra Pradesh. NTPC is facilitating 15GW of reverse auction solar tenders by 2019 on behalf of the government, in addition to its own 10GW of solar projects.

Facilitated by a US$50 billion grid upgrade, solar electricity is key, with installs of 75GW by 2021/22 capable of delivering 110TWh,or 22% of the required electricity increase.

“India is replicating Germany’s and China’s systematic electricity sector transformation, with the added advantage that the cost effectiveness of this is accentuated by the fact that the price of solar electricity has dropped by 80% in 5 years,” said Tim Buckley, Director of Energy Finance Studies at IEEFA.

According to IEEFA, taking wind installs to 60GW could deliver 18% of the required uplift, with a combined capacity expansion across nuclear, gas, biomass and hydro providing a further 26%.

In this context, the Government of India’s ambition to more than double Indian domestic coal production to 1,500Mtpa by 2021/22 would oversupply India with coal by 400Mtpa, with dire consequences for the seaborne thermal coal market.

While many commodity forecasters have assumed Indian imports will continue to grow, as a result of the transformation, IEEFA forecasts a peak in Indian thermal coal imports in 2015, with a rapid ~20% pa decline thereafter.

Energy Minister Goyal has made it clear that India’s reliance on thermal coal imports is not sustainable for the economy, rate payers nor commercially viable for the coal-fired power plants involved. Goyal in May 2015 said: “We are confident that in the next year or two, we will be able to stop imports of thermal coal.”

In July 2015, the Telangana and Madhya Pradesh state solar tender awards highlighted that solar electricity costs are already lower than that of imported coal-fired power generation. The tariffs agreed for solar were around 1 rupee/kWh cheaper than electricity from imported thermal coal and fixed for 25 years, which will result in a considerable deflationary impact.

“With falling prices of solar, imported coal has become the most expensive source of incremental electricity generation,” said Jai Sharda, co author and a financial expert from Equatorial research. “As momentum builds, it is inevitable that the Indian electricity market will rapidly pivoting toward a significantly higher reliance on renewable energy and energy efficiency,” Sharda continued.

“This is predicated on the fact that once built, renewable energy plants and energy efficiency initiatives have an almost zero marginal cost of production; while coal-fired power plants have a high marginal cost of production. Furthermore, Minister Goyal’s plan to access global debt capital markets will significantly lower the cost of renewables in India and accelerate the transition.”

About IEEFA

The Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis (IEEFA) conducts research and analyses on financial and economic issues related to energy and the environment. The Institute’s mission is to accelerate the transition to a diverse, sustainable and profitable energy economy and to reduce dependence on coal and other non-renewable energy resources.

Source: http://ieefa.org/category/subject/reports/